Castanet
Wine Gourmet
Syrah and Shiraz are the same grape variety.  The Wine Gourmet gives some great suggestions for selection.
Syrah and Shiraz are the same grape variety. The Wine Gourmet gives some great suggestions for selection.

Syrah or Shiraz?
by Contributed - Story: 39489
May 23, 2008 / 5:00 am

"What's in a name?
That which we call a Syrah/Shiraz by any other name would smell as sweet".


With apologies to William Shakespeare for destroying his much-revered quote from Romeo and Juliet, Syrah/Shiraz has been causing some confusion over the past few years. Numerous myths and legends have existed about its origin and the differences between the two.

First off, they are the same variety. It was thought that the name came from the legend that the grape originally came from the Iranian city of Shiraz, which was brought to southern France by a returning crusader, Guy De'Sterimberg or by the Greeks, depending on which story you are reading. It is also thought to have acquired its name from a story that the Romans brought the grape to the Rhone Valley from Syracuse, in Italy, during their occupation.

However, DNA profiling performed by Professor Carole Meredith at the University of California at Davis and Jean-Michel Boursiquot at the wine research facility at Montpellier, France in 1998, determined that Syrah is indigenous to the Rhone valley of France. It is a natural cross of Dureza from the northern Ardeche region, west of the Rhone and Mondeuse Blanche, native to the Savoie region, to the east of the Rhone. How this love-match came to be is anyone’s guess but it is known that the grape was growing around the time of the Roman occupation in the 1st century AD. From France, the vine found its way to Australia courtesy of James Busby who, after studying viticulture in France, took 437 vine cuttings with him to Australia in 1831.

In Australia, it is the most widely planted grape, typically representing 40% of the red grape crush and one-fifth of total grape production and there are distinctive styles of Shiraz that have emerged. It can be made into a wide range, defined by the terroir of the region and the winemakers' artistry, from the elegant, peppery cool climate styles (Heathcote in Victoria) to more intensely flavoured spicy styles of Coonawarra and Margaret River to powerful and minty (Clare Valley), sweet and chocolaty (McLaren Vale), muscular, and ripe-fruited (Barossa), and leathery and rich (Hunter Valley). In an attempt to allow regional characters to be expressed, many winemakers are moving away from 100% new American oak, preferring the use of older barrels and/or French oak. The result is an abundance of new styles with finesse and complexity.

Recognized as Shiraz mainly in Australia, some Shiraz’s are also produced in California. A relative newcomer to California, vine cuttings were brought to California only in 1936 by Dr. Harold P. Olmo of the University of California, Davis. However, it has only been in the last decade that the U.S. has gone ga-ga for Syrah/Shiraz.

Syrah, on the other hand, is known for the big, muscular wines of the northern Rhone and as one of the varieties for the production of Châteauneuf-du-Pape. In the northern Rhone, they are not categorized as Syrah but are labeled as Hermitage, Crozes-Hermitage and Cote Rôtie. Here the grape produces wines that are raspberry and blackcurrant-scented with hints of cherry, smoke and roasted meat. In the southern Rhone, it is used as blending material where it provides the necessary colour and fragrance.

To further confuse matters, there is a variety called Petite Sirah that is actually a cross-pollination with a French grape called Durif and a variety called Peloursin. This grape was developed by a Dr. Durif around 1880, in his experimental vineyard at the University of Montpellier in southern France.

Whichever style you favour, there is no denying the fact this grape is becoming very popular. If you have not tried either style yet, get down to your local bottle shop, pick up a few, and have a Syrah-Shiraz party. That is what wine is for...enjoyment with family and friends.

In Vino Veritas
Jim Martin

Weekend Wine Picks: A selection of Shiraz/Syrah

From Chile, the 2006 Casillero del Diablo Shiraz ($14 GLS) has everything you would want in a Shiraz. With a deep, rich colour, this is loaded to the brim with tons of blackberry, cassis, black plum jam-like fruit with hints of chocolate, licorice, tar, roasted meat, sage, smoke, menthol and vanilla. The palate is rich, lush and spicy with lots of black fruit, spicy pepper, crisp, smoky acidity and medium tannins. One of best bang-for-your-bucks Syrah/Shiraz on the market, this should be on everyone’s summer wine list.

One of the top selling wines in BC, the 2007 Obikwa Shiraz ($11-$12 PWS & GLS) is extravagantly rich and flavoursome, at a truly remarkable price. Displaying characteristics of a wine at a much larger price point, this wine is full of rich, smoky/roasted red peppers, blackberry, cassis, and blueberry, with hints of prunes, licorice, leather, black olives and savoury herbs. The texture on the palate is medium-bodied with prune, blackberry, leather, tobacco and menthol. Soft acidity and medium tannins round out this spectacular QPR. Excellent with grilled baby back ribs, lamb chops or steak.

A soft and juicy wine from the Costières de Nîmes in southern France, the 2005 Chateau de Valcombe Syrah-Grenache ($13-$15 PWS & GLS) is a blend 70% Syrah and 30% Grenache coming from the oldest vines on the Valcombe property. It is not a big, muscular wine but it is a concentrated, opaque purple coloured wine, full of soft, rich, blackberry, and black plum jam aromas with dark chocolate, chocolate, smoke and vanilla notes. The flavours are ripe and flavourful with excellent weight and balance. While it is delicious to enjoy right now, it could be cellared away for another year. Let it breathe for an hour or so and serve with roasts, beef stew, lamb, or strong cheeses. Love the screwcap.

Argentina continues its dominance in the BC market and prime example of the reason why is the 2006 Pascual Toso Syrah ($15 PWS). This tasty little BBQ red is loaded with savoury blackberry, cassis, black plum, and blueberry, literally full of delicious fruit aromas with hints of roasted sausage, roasted red peppers, licorice, chocolate, vanilla, cedar and spicy pepper. The texture is chunky and full with ripe black fruit, pepper, tobacco leaf, cedar and smoke. Rich velvety finish with soft acidity and ultra-firm tannins, this wine could do with some cellaring but it is perfect with any type of grilled red meats.

The new vintage of this perennial great buy has been released and the 2006 Jackson Triggs Reserve Shiraz ($20-$25 PWS & GLS) seems to be a repeat of the very successful ’05. Displaying an abundant, heady aroma of rich cassis, blackberry, and raspberry jam-like qualities with vanilla, chocolate, and smoke, the texture on the palate is pure hedonism with its lush black fruit texture with hints of vanilla, chocolate and leather with velvety soft acidity and firm tannins. A very well balanced wine, it can be enjoyed now for the sheer pleasure of it or cellar for another 3-5 years.

A stunning expression of Aussie Shiraz, the 2006 Winners Tank Shiraz ($29 PWS) is a perennial “Best Buy” when it comes to Aussie reds. Chock full of super-ripe blackberry, blueberry, boyensberry and cassis-like character with licorice, menthol, roasted coffee beans, and tobacco leaf. The palate is rich and lush with juicy black fruit, black pepper spice, velvety soft acidity and firm tannins. An absolutely killer red from Langhorne Creek.





About the author...

Jim Martin has been involved with the wine and spirits industry for more than three decades. Originally from Vancouver where he started with the provincial BCLDB, Jim discovered a passion for wine in 1977 when he stumbled across a 1975 Bordeaux that was a revelation to him. This led to delving further into wine appreciation through constant tasting and evaluation of the different regions of the world. Trying his hand at making wine from Zinfandel grapes one year gave him an appreciation for the trials and tribulations encountered by winemakers. The wine turned out to be spectacular.

A turning point was in 1986 when he was placed in charge of the wine selection at one of the top specialty wine stores in B.C. Through this he became involved with the specialty wine store at the Vancouver International Wine festival from 1988-1992. All of these events led to his advancement to the position of Wine Consultant at key specialty wine stores in West Vancouver and Whistler where he set up the wine selections and helped restaurants develop their wine lists. It was while in Whistler that he acquired the nickname "Corky".

In 1996, after returning to work from a lengthy illness, he felt it was time for a move and left the lower mainland for the sunny climes of the Okanagan, settling in Kelowna with his wife Patti and their 4 children. Here he became involved with the local wine industry by sitting on the VQA panel and serving as a wine judge on occasion. He also continued to work with restaurants, speaking at wine events and dinners.

In 2004, he left the BCLDB for the private sector becoming involved in the opening of Kelowna's first private specialty wine store, Waterfront Wines and most recently with Metro Liquor. He was instrumental in developing an email newsletter while at the LDB and expanding it at Waterfront Wines and Central Park to now include almost 700 people who receive up-to-date wine news every week. Jim started writing the Wine Gourmet column for Castanet on a wide variety of subjects pertaining to wine and the global wine industry in the fall of 2004.

Jim is well respected by the wine community and is best known for his approachable and knowledgeable style. Constantly trying to de-emphasize the snobbery of wine, Jim is friendly and easy to talk to about all aspects of wines.

You can reach Martin at 763-2600 or email jim.martin@castanet.net or visit their website on Castanet.






The views expressed are strictly those of the author and not necessarily those of Castanet. Castanet presents its columns "as is" and does not warrant the contents.



Previous Stories




RSS this page.
(Click for RSS instructions.)
© 2008 Castanet.net